Ebenezer: A Christmas Carol Gets a Johnny Depp Makeover… But Is It Worth the Big Screen? 🎄

This afternoon was a busy one.


I did some shopping for Starbucks merchandise, had a couple of doctor's appointments, visited Mom, and then decided it was time to squeeze in a movie.


Today's selection: Ebenezer, starring Johnny Depp, Rupert Grint of Harry Potter fame, Daisy Ridley of Star Wars fame, Ian McKellen of Lord of the Rings fame, and others.


I had a choice between this and How to Rob a Bank.


I went with Ebenezer because I noticed other theaters were showing it in RPX, Regal's upgraded theater experience. That made me think this might be one of those movies that would benefit from a big screen and upgraded sound.


Was I right?


Well... let's get into it.


Another trip to Christmas Past

We've had plenty of versions of Charles Dickens' A Christmas Carol over the years.


I've watched Scrooged with Bill Murray, which was a lot of fun. There's the 1984 version starring George C. Scott, Mickey's Christmas Carol featuring Scrooge McDuck, and plenty of other interpretations.

So what makes this one different?


This version spends more time exploring how Ebenezer Scrooge became the crotchety, miserable cheapskate we know.

The story begins with Jacob Marley, Ebenezer's business partner at a firm. Both men are obsessed with work and money. A tragedy takes place, leaving Ebenezer behind at the firm with employee Bob Cratchit.


And then the familiar Christmas story begins.


Before the three ghosts arrive, another ghost appears to warn Ebenezer that he will be visited.

You know what's coming next: Christmas Past, Christmas Present, and Christmas Future.


But this movie takes a longer route to get there.

More background, more Scrooge

One thing this version does differently is give us more of Ebenezer's history.


We learn more about his sister, his father, his school days, and his love interest. We get a clearer look at the experiences that shaped the man he eventually became.


Christmas Present gives us more insight into his nephew, his friends and family, and how they view Ebenezer.

We also spend time with Bob Cratchit's family and Tiny Tim, including the struggles they're facing.


Then there's Christmas Future, showing what may happen if Ebenezer continues down the path he's chosen.


The traditional story gives us a glimpse into his past, present, and potential future. This version expands on those pieces and tries to give us a fuller picture of the man behind the miserable exterior.


I appreciated that approach.


But there's a difference between adding more story and making the story move better.


And that's where things started to get a little sluggish for me.


Christmas Past was intense. The rest? Not so much.

After Christmas Past, the movie's pacing started to drag.


That first visit was intense and, at times, genuinely unsettling. It wasn't scary enough to call this a horror movie, but it definitely had some moments that got my attention.

Unfortunately, the momentum didn't carry through the rest of the visits.


Christmas Present and Christmas Future felt longer than they needed to be.


I found myself waiting for the story to move along.


That's a directorial decision, and in my opinion, it doesn't work.


Just because you have more backstory to tell doesn't mean every part of the story needs to take longer to tell it.


Sometimes less is more.


Johnny Depp: I could barely hear you, Ebenezer!

Let's talk about Johnny Depp.


He plays Ebenezer with a very thick 1830s English accent. I suspect he spent a considerable amount of time learning and developing that particular way of speaking.

The problem?


It was super thick, super soft, and difficult for me to understand throughout the movie.


I'm an American audience member, and I found myself struggling to catch some of what he was saying.


An accent can certainly add authenticity to a character, but there's a point where the performance becomes difficult to follow.


I don't need every actor to sound like they're from Mount Pleasant, South Carolina, but I would like to understand the dialogue without working overtime.


And when the lead character is difficult to hear, that's a problem.


Would RPX be worth it?

Here's why I picked this movie over How to Rob a Bank.


I saw that other theaters were showing Ebenezer in RPX, and I figured the bigger screen and upgraded sound would make this a better theatrical experience.


I have Regal Unlimited, so I didn't pay extra to see it. That certainly makes the decision easier.


But even with the upgraded presentation, I didn't feel the movie delivered enough visual or audio spectacle to justify making it a priority for a big-screen viewing.


There wasn't enough pizzazz.


It didn't strike me as the kind of movie that needed to occupy multiple screens and different theater formats for an extended period.

The visuals and sound weren't bad. They just weren't enough to make me say, "You HAVE to see this in a theater!"


My verdict: Save it for a cozy night at home

I didn't dislike Ebenezer. I appreciated the expanded backstory and the fresh take on a familiar Christmas tale.


The cast is impressive, and it's interesting to see more of the experiences that shaped Scrooge.


But the pacing after Christmas Past was a problem for me, and Johnny Depp's very thick, quiet accent made parts of the dialogue difficult to follow.


This isn't a must-see on the big screen.

In fact, I think it might be better enjoyed at home, where you can settle into your living room, light a fire, and pour yourself some eggnog or Coquito.

No need to fight for the best theater seat or crank up the volume.

My recommendation: Wait for streaming.

And if you do watch it, let me know what you thought. Did you enjoy the expanded backstory? Did Johnny Depp's accent work for you? Or did you find the pacing as slow as I did?

Thanks for reading peeps.

For more movie reviews and all the other good, bad, and stupid... Head over to NielFlamm.com.

Or don't. Till next time!

Previous
Previous

The Hinge Experiment: Whiplash, MRI, Lawyers, and the BMW X6 Insurance Claim

Next
Next

Help Dexter Reid Reach the Top Host Semifinals!