Day 143: Nextdoor Doesn't Own the Verified Address — The U.S. Postal Service Has Been Doing This for Centuries
Today, while picking up my mail, I came across something that got me thinking. It was a collection of unexpected advertisements, but they all had something in common.
They had my name. They had my mailing address. And they were trying to sell me something.
Sound familiar? You might be receiving the same kind of mail.
Some were from real estate agents offering to evaluate my home's value. Others were from LeafFilter, a former employer of mine, and an HVAC company offering services or a new heating and cooling unit.
So why am I bringing this up in my ongoing Nextdoor case study?
Because Nextdoor doesn't have a monopoly on verified addresses.
The verified address isn't a new invention
Nirav Tolia frequently highlights verified addresses, along with AI, as important differentiators for the Nextdoor platform.
And I understand why knowing that someone is connected to a particular neighborhood can be valuable. It can help create a more localized experience and give advertisers a way to reach people in specific communities.
But let's not pretend that connecting a name to a physical mailing address is some groundbreaking technological achievement.
The United States Postal Service has been delivering mail to addresses for generations.
In fact, the U.S. Postal Service dates back to July 26, 1775, when the Second Continental Congress established the position of Postmaster General and laid the foundation for the American postal system.
That's more than 250 years of connecting people, businesses, and physical addresses.
Businesses already know how to reach households
Think about the companies sending these advertisements.
Real estate agents want homeowners who might be interested in knowing their property's value.
HVAC companies want homeowners who may need maintenance, repairs, or a replacement system.
Home improvement companies want to reach people who might need their products and services.
They can use bulk mailing through the United States Postal Service to put their message directly into a household's mailbox.
They don't need Nextdoor to verify my address.
They don't need a social media account to know where I live.
They don't need an AI assistant to figure out which neighborhood I belong to.
They have a mailing address and a way to reach me.
Of course, direct mail and digital advertising are different channels. Nextdoor can offer targeting, engagement, and interaction that a postcard cannot. I'm not suggesting they're identical.
But the larger point remains: verified addresses are not exclusive to Nextdoor, and they aren't a new concept.
So what's the real competitive advantage?
If Nextdoor wants to promote verified addresses as a major selling point, I'd like to understand what makes its approach meaningfully different.
Is it the ability to target specific neighborhoods?
Is it the ability to combine location information with community interests and engagement?
Is it the quality of the audience data?
Is it better conversion measurement for advertisers?
Those are legitimate questions, and those are the kinds of things that could distinguish a digital advertising platform.
But a verified address alone isn't enough to build a competitive advantage. The real value comes from what a company can do with that information, how responsibly it uses it, and whether it delivers measurable results for advertisers.
And that brings me right back to my recurring question about Nextdoor: What exactly are small businesses getting for their advertising dollars, and how does Nextdoor demonstrate the value?
Nirav, the mailbox has been around for a while
I appreciate that Nextdoor wants to highlight its technology, AI capabilities, and verified neighborhood connections.
But sometimes I think the company spends so much time promoting what it believes makes it unique that it overlooks the fact that many of these concepts have existed for a very long time.
The next time Nextdoor talks about verified addresses as a major differentiator, perhaps someone should take a walk to the mailbox.
The U.S. Postal Service has been connecting businesses with households since the days of the Continental Congress.
Day 143. The mail keeps coming, the questions keep coming, and apparently, verified addresses aren't exactly a new invention.
Nirav, more feedback for you!
Day 133: Nextdoor Has Time for AI. What About Protecting Neighbor Data?
Monday. Just before noon.
It's been a slow day on Nextdoor. I missed Day 132 because there wasn't much to report. Now, four days have passed without a public response to the questions I've been raising about moderator accountability, neighbor privacy, and protecting nonpublic information.
Nirav Tolia hasn't responded to those questions either.
At this point, the silence feels routine.
Meanwhile, I checked NXDR this morning. The stock is trading around $2.37, down from $2.63 on Friday. That's a notable move, although I have no evidence connecting it to anything I've been discussing.
But the stock price isn't today's story.
Today's story is what Nextdoor chooses to talk about—and what it doesn't.
Day 133: The Questions Are Still There
My question is straightforward.
What safeguards does Nextdoor have to protect neighbors if a volunteer moderator misuses their position or accesses nonpublic information for purposes unrelated to moderation?
I'm not accusing a specific moderator of misconduct. I'm asking about the controls that should exist before something goes wrong.
Nextdoor's U.S. Member Agreement says that volunteers who have access to nonpublic information through account features must use it only in connection with their volunteer role. That's an important rule.
But a rule is only one part of a safeguard.
What limits access in the first place? How does Nextdoor monitor potential misuse? What happens when a neighbor reports that a moderator has abused their privileges? How does Nextdoor investigate complaints when the person being reported is part of the moderation system?
And what training must moderators complete to understand their responsibilities around confidentiality, conflicts of interest, and personal retaliation?
I want Nextdoor to publicly explain these protections in plain English.
Not because I know a breach has happened. I don't.
Not because I know a moderator has misused nonpublic information. I don't.
I want the company to explain how it prevents these things from happening and how it responds if they do.
AI Days: An Interesting Initiative, but Is It the Priority Neighbors Need?
Last week, Tony Castellanos, Nextdoor's head of People, highlighted the company's monthly AI Days—time set aside for employees to experiment with AI tools and explore ways to improve their work. HR Brew also covered the initiative.
Experimentation can be useful. Companies should explore tools that help employees work more effectively.
My concern isn't that Nextdoor is exploring AI.
My concern is the difference between the topics the company promotes and the practical questions users still need answered.
We hear about AI experimentation, neighborhood-level advertising intelligence and product initiatives. Those subjects may be relevant to Nextdoor's business strategy.
But where is the equally clear public explanation of how the company protects the people who make its platform valuable?
Where is the straightforward discussion of moderator access, confidentiality, accountability and safeguards against retaliation?
AI can help a company move faster. It cannot replace sound policies, effective oversight or accountability.
Nirav Tolia, What Are the Safeguards?
Nirav, I'm not asking you to respond personally to every post I publish. I'm asking Nextdoor, as a company built around verified neighbors and local relationships, to explain how it protects the information and trust those relationships depend on.
Here are the questions I'd like answered:
Access: What nonpublic information can volunteer moderators access, and how is that access restricted?
Monitoring: What controls detect or investigate potential misuse of moderator privileges?
Training: Is annual refresher or compliance training mandatory for volunteer moderators? What does it cover?
Complaints: How can neighbors report suspected moderator abuse without fear of retaliation?
Accountability: Who reviews serious complaints when the moderator is the subject of the report?
Transparency: Where can users read a clear explanation of these safeguards and how they're enforced?
Nextdoor's public policies provide some information about expected conduct. What I want to understand is how the company puts those expectations into practice.
Publishing the rules is important. Explaining the protections behind them is important, too.
Four Days of Silence, Another Day of Questions
I started this case study to examine the gap between Nextdoor's promise and its execution.
I'm still doing that.
I don't expect a response to every question, and I recognize that the company can't disclose every detail of its security procedures. There are legitimate reasons not to publish information that could help someone circumvent a security control.
But there's a difference between revealing sensitive technical details and explaining the principles, training, oversight, and accountability measures used to protect people.
A company can be transparent about its approach without giving bad actors a roadmap.
That's what I'm asking for.
As I write this on Monday, October 26, NXDR is down from Friday's close, and, from my perspective, my questions about moderator safeguards remain unanswered. The stock movement is one data point. The unanswered questions are a separate issue.
Nextdoor has announced that its next earnings report will come on November 5. Investors will hear about business performance, and I'm sure there will be plenty to discuss.
But I hope Nextdoor also remembers that its long-term future depends on more than revenue, engagement, and new technology.
It depends on whether neighbors can trust the platform—and whether the company can demonstrate that it takes their privacy and safety seriously.
Stop making AI the headline for a moment. Tell neighbors how you're protecting them.
That's the update I'm waiting for.
👉 Follow my continuing Nextdoor case study at NielFlamm.com/blog.
🎃 Day 120: Halloween, Neighbors, and Another Day of Silence from Nextdoor
Halloween could be an AWESOME opportunity for Nextdoor to bring neighbors together. Think about it!
🍬 Kids smiling from ear to ear as they collect candy.
🍫 Adults secretly stealing candy from their own kids.
🏡 Neighbors hosting Halloween parties and welcoming people into their homes.
👻 Communities coming together for a holiday that so many people love.
That's what a neighborhood platform should do: connect people, build relationships, and bring communities together.
But let's check in on Nextdoor's leadership and communications.
📅 Nextdoor's last post: October 8.
📅 Nirav Tolia's last post: October 9.
If Nirav isn't talking about AI, is he talking about anything at all? 🤔
Meanwhile, NXDR is trading at $2.66 a share today. That's movement in the right direction, but it's still a far cry from the Citibank number Nextdoor previously referenced.
And here's the bigger question: What about the people whose data helps power the platform?
Nextdoor benefits from its users' activity, information, and contributions. Shouldn't those users have a voice in how the value generated from their data is shared?
📢 Have you signed the Nextdoor Neighbor Value-Sharing Petition?
If you believe neighbors deserve a share in the value created by their contributions, add your name today!
✍️ Sign the petition here: https://c.org/GkNWmffgg9
Let's keep the conversation going. A neighborhood platform should be about more than AI announcements and stock prices. It should be about the people who make the neighborhoods — and the platform — what they are.
🎃 Happy Halloween! Let's make it about neighbors again.
The Free Data Buffet Is Over: If Our Content Creates Value, We Should Share in It
A while ago, I started a petition asking a fairly simple question:
If Nextdoor can create economic value from information neighbors provide, why shouldn't the neighbors who provide it participate in that value?
Today, I'm expanding the question.
This isn't only about Nextdoor anymore.
It's about social media platforms, websites, apps, advertising networks, and other digital businesses that collect information about what we read, click, search, recommend, review, discuss, and buy.
My message is becoming simpler:
Our information isn't free anymore.
At least, I don't think it should be.
We Keep Supplying the Raw Material
Think about what people give digital platforms every day.
We write reviews. We recommend restaurants. We tell neighbors which plumber showed up on time. We answer questions. We upload photographs. We comment. We click. We search. We like things. We tell platforms what interests us.
Then there's the less obvious information: cookies, device identifiers, IP addresses, browsing activity, clicks and other event data.
These aren't all legally or technically the same thing, and different privacy laws and platform agreements govern how different types of information may be collected and used. I'm not claiming that placing a cookie on my browser magically means somebody owes me a royalty check.
I'm making an argument about economic value.
Because individually, one click may be almost meaningless.
Multiply those clicks, posts, recommendations, and behavioral signals across millions of people, however, and suddenly we're talking about an extremely valuable resource.
Nextdoor Makes the Point Particularly Well
Nextdoor increasingly describes itself in terms of neighbor-generated knowledge. Its 2025 Transparency Report described the platform as containing “neighbor-generated content and locally relevant information,” while Nextdoor's newer AI-powered Ask product draws upon nearly 15 years of conversations among verified neighbors. Nextdoor
That's valuable.
And who created those conversations?
Neighbors did.
Nextdoor built the platform.
Nextdoor paid engineers.
Nextdoor created the infrastructure.
Nextdoor developed the advertising business.
Nextdoor has every right to try to build a profitable company from those investments.
But neighbors supplied an enormous amount of the raw material that makes the platform useful.
Nextdoor itself says almost 30% of its content consists of organic recommendations and has talked about tens of millions of “Faves” associated with millions of businesses. Nextdoor Blog
That's nothing.
Cookies Are Part of the Bigger Conversation
The same principle makes me think differently about tracking.
Nextdoor's own data-processing documentation identifies things such as cookie IDs or similar identifiers, IP addresses, user-agent information, and event data such as clicks or installs among categories of personal data involved in certain advertising-related processing. Nextdoor Legal
Again, this isn't uniquely a Nextdoor issue.
It's an internet issue.
We've spent years becoming accustomed to clicking:
ACCEPT ALL COOKIES
Maybe we should start thinking more carefully about what we're accepting and what companies receive in return.
If information about my behavior helps improve targeting, train recommendation systems, develop products, measure advertising, build audiences or otherwise contribute to commercial value, I think it's reasonable to have a larger conversation about what the person generating that information receives in return.
Welcome Back to My Very Lonely Petition 😂
My petition hasn't exactly become the Boston Tea Party of user-generated data.
Last time I checked, it had one signature.
Mine.
😂
I already know what that guy thinks.
But perhaps my original message was too focused on Nextdoor.
Because this question is much bigger.
My updated message isn't:
Destroy social media.
It isn't:
Stop using the internet.
And it certainly isn't:
Companies shouldn't make money.
It's this:
If our participation creates commercial value, let's start talking about sharing that value.
That could take many forms.
Direct compensation for opt-in research. Contribution credits. Subscription benefits. Revenue-sharing pools. Advertising credits. Payments for particularly valuable content. Rewards for reviews or recommendations that generate measurable commercial activity. Stronger controls over commercial reuse. Clear choices about whether content can be used to develop AI products.
I don't pretend to have the perfect economic model.
That's what the conversation is for.
Until Then, We Can Stop Supplying Some of the Commodity
That's the other part of my petition.
Participation is voluntary.
If I don't like the economic arrangement, I can reconsider what I voluntarily contribute.
That doesn't mean withholding information about a missing child, dangerous weather, a lost pet, a fire, an emergency, or something that could protect another person.
Human safety comes before my argument about data economics.
I'm talking about the routine commercial material platforms benefit from:
Which roofer should I hire?
What's the best restaurant nearby?
Who installed your HVAC system?
Would you recommend this dealership?
Which insurance company do you use?
Every answer adds another tiny piece to a valuable database.
Maybe we should stop automatically assuming that contribution costs $0.00.
The Internet Made Us the Product, the Customer and the Workforce
That's what fascinates me.
We can simultaneously be the audience viewing advertisements, the customer purchasing products, the creator producing content, and the source generating behavioral data.
That's an extraordinary business model.
For the companies.
Maybe it's time users become more conscious participants in the economics too.
And I'm not suggesting that users automatically have a legal right to payment for everything they post or every cookie generated. Platform terms, privacy laws, and individual choices matter.
I'm saying something much simpler:
We can ask for a different deal.
Nextdoor, You're Still My Test Case
Nextdoor remains particularly interesting to me because its product depends so heavily on what neighbors know.
Without neighbors, there are no neighbor recommendations.
Without neighbors, AI has no years of neighborhood conversations to search.
Without neighbors, there are no local experiences to organize.
Without neighbors, advertisers have far less reason to want access to those neighborhoods.
Nextdoor says it wants every voice to have value. Nextdoor Business
Great.
Let's talk about the economic value too.
Nextdoor built the container.
Neighbors keep filling it.
So I'm Updating the Invitation
To Nextdoor.
To social-media companies.
To websites.
To apps.
To companies collecting behavioral information.
And, most importantly, to the people creating all of it:
Stop thinking of your digital activity as automatically worthless simply because nobody has historically written you a check for it.
Ask what you're providing.
Ask how it's being used.
Read the privacy controls.
Decline unnecessary tracking when you prefer not to.
Think before voluntarily providing another commercially useful recommendation, review, or piece of content.
And if enough people decide the current exchange isn't good enough?
Companies will have an incentive to offer a better one.
My petition may still have only one signature.
That's okay.
Every movement has a first person willing to look slightly ridiculous standing there alone.
I'm already bald. I've survived worse. 😂
Our information has value.
Our content has value.
Our recommendations have value.
Our attention has value.
Our time has value.
The question isn't whether digital companies should be allowed to create value.
The question is whether the people supplying so much of the raw material should be part of it.
I think that's a conversation worth having.
👉 Sign the petition: https://c.org/GkNWmffgg9
👉 Follow the continuing case study: NielFlamm.com/blog
Nextdoor’s Identity Question: Community Platform or Data & Advertising Company?
I continue to look more deeply into Nextdoor, not only as a shareholder but also as someone trying to understand its long-term vision, strategy, and execution.
Nextdoor recently released its 2026 Back-to-School Research, which discusses today’s parents, the importance of neighborhoods, local recommendations, and how communities support each other.
On the surface, this aligns with the message CEO Nirav Tolia often shares — building connection, strengthening communities, using AI to improve the neighbor experience, and bringing people together.
I support that mission.
The challenge is that the messaging starts to feel contradictory when compared to other leadership conversations.
In a recent interview, Chief Revenue Officer Michael Kiernan discussed Nextdoor’s future revenue strategy, AI transformation, and new monetization opportunities.
He discussed how Nextdoor has over 110 million people on the platform, and how the company understands neighbors — where they live, their interests, their communities, and how they engage. He also discussed how the “neighborhood graph” could become a monetization asset.
From a business perspective, I understand this.
Nextdoor is a publicly traded company. It has shareholders. It has expenses. It needs sustainable revenue.
Advertising, partnerships, AI efficiency, and new revenue streams are expected parts of running a technology company.
But here is where I continue to ask questions:
Where does the neighbor fit into the equation?
If surveys and neighbor insights are valuable enough to promote to advertisers, partners, and the public, shouldn’t the full research methodology be transparent?
How many people participated?
How were participants selected?
What were the demographics?
What questions were asked?
What was the complete data set?
Today marks Day 22 since I requested the full research information from Jacob Chavis regarding previous Nextdoor studies.
No full study.
No methodology.
No response.
That is where trust becomes difficult.
A company cannot talk about transparency, trust, and an authentic community while also controlling which information neighbors and investors are allowed to see.
The bigger question:
Is Nextdoor a neighborhood platform that creates revenue opportunities by connecting people?
Or is Nextdoor becoming a data and advertising company powered by neighbor activity?
Those are two very different stories.
Maybe the answer is somewhere in the middle — but that requires transparency.
Neighbors deserve clarity.
Advertisers deserve clarity.
Shareholders deserve clarity.
Trust is not created through messaging.
Trust is created through actions.
Join the discussion on NielFlamm.com.