Day 154: Nextdoor's Accountability Gap — 154 Days and Counting

Another email. Another day. And another opportunity for Nextdoor leadership to respond.


Today marks Day 154 since I first asked Jacob Chavis, Senior Manager of Customer Insights at Nextdoor, for the complete research study and methodology.


One hundred fifty-four days.


At this point, I think it's fair to say that this request has become more than just a request for a research document. It's become a case study in communication, transparency, and accountability.


So, I sent another email to Nirav Tolia and the Nextdoor leadership team.


And this time, I wanted to put several things into perspective.


While Nextdoor keeps moving, the request remains unresolved

Over the past several weeks, Nextdoor has been busy.


  • Publishing new research-themed blog posts.

  • Announcing product developments and AI-powered features.

  • Celebrating its move from the NYSE to Nasdaq.

  • Bringing product and engineering teams together in San Francisco.

  • Participating in investor conferences.

  • Sharing leadership messages about building a product that people want to return to.


There's certainly no shortage of corporate activity or public communication.


But when it comes to providing the research study and methodology that I originally requested, there's been no meaningful response.


I'm not asking for confidential financial information or access to internal company systems.


I'm asking for the complete study referenced in a publicly available Nextdoor blog post.


If it's available, provide it. If it can't be shared, explain why. If Jacob Chavis is no longer the appropriate contact, identify someone who can address the request.


That's not an unreasonable expectation.


And then there's the stock price

I also included the recent NXDR stock performance in my email.


Here's the comparison:

That's a decline of approximately 16.4% from the November 4 closing price.


Of course, I can't attribute that decline to any single announcement, decision, or issue. Stock prices move for many reasons.


But the decline raises legitimate questions about investor confidence and whether Nextdoor can translate its product development, user growth, and advertising opportunities into sustainable revenue and profitability.


A Nasdaq listing, a new product announcement, or an inspirational post from the CEO doesn't automatically change the financial picture.


Investors ultimately want results.


Three principles, one big question

Recently, Nirav Tolia shared three principles discussed during a gathering of Nextdoor's product and engineering teams with Bing Gordon:


  1. Respect the time.

  2. Earn the return.

  3. Build in other people.


I actually like those principles.


But I keep coming back to the question: does Nextdoor apply them consistently?


Respect the time: What about people who spend time creating content, participating in discussions, and trying to resolve moderation issues?


Earn the return: What gives users a reason to come back? Is the platform delivering a consistently useful experience?


Build in other people: What about the neighbors, small businesses, and local publishers who contribute to the platform's value?


And what about people who provide feedback directly to the company?


I would argue that listening to feedback is part of building a product people want to use.


You can't promote the importance of community while leaving people wondering whether anyone at the company is paying attention.


What I asked leadership to do

My latest email wasn't complicated. I asked for four things:


  • Provide the complete research study and methodology.

  • If Jacob Chavis is no longer the appropriate contact, identify someone who can help.

  • If the study cannot be shared, explain why.

  • Explain the process for submitting customer and community feedback and receiving a response.


I also reiterated that I'm willing to have a conversation by phone, video, or even virtual coffee.


I'm not looking for an argument. I'm looking for answers.


I would much rather write a blog post about Nextdoor leadership engaging constructively, addressing questions, and resolving an outstanding issue than continue documenting the lack of response.


The email

Here's the email I sent to Nirav Tolia and the Nextdoor leadership team.

The subject line was:

Day 154: Nextdoor's Accountability Gap — 154 Days and Counting

I wanted the email to reflect the bigger picture: the company's public messaging, its financial performance, and the difference between talking about accountability and demonstrating it.

Day 154: The absence of a response becomes part of the story

There's something rather interesting about a company that talks about respecting people's time, earning their return, and building connections, while a request for information remains unresolved for 154 days.

I'm not suggesting that one unanswered email explains Nextdoor's stock performance. That would be an unreasonable conclusion.

But communication and trust matter.

They matter to customers. They matter to advertisers. They matter to the neighbors who use the platform. And they matter to investors.

Nextdoor has an opportunity to change the narrative.

It can answer questions, provide research, explain the process, and show that feedback is more than something mentioned in a corporate presentation.

Day 154. At some point, the absence of a response becomes part of the story.

I'm giving Nextdoor another opportunity to change that narrative.

Nirav, the invitation remains open.

👉 Follow the ongoing case study at NielFlamm.com/blog.

Previous
Previous

The Hinge Experiment: Black Friday in New York City, Harry Potter, Shopping, and a Very Expensive Thank You to Roach!

Next
Next

A 12-Pack of Corona at the Skilled Nursing Facility? Well, That's an Unexpected Surprise!